Skip to main content

Off-site External Hard Drive Backup Rotation for SOHO

Thread needs solution

I have a need to create a backup solution for a Client with the following requirements. The subject computer is a Windows XP workstation used as a peer-to-peer server, two hard disks (OS and Data), with around 32 Gb total space used.
1. 4 external hard disk (USB 3) backup devices initially, automatically allowing the addition of new backup drives when needed or desired.
2. Only one backup drive connected at a time, for a calendar week.
3. Backup drive will be changed once per week, exchanged for one of the off-site drives in an organized or random rotation.
4. Full system image backup run the first night, automatically by schedule (11 PM)
5. Incremental file backups made each other night of the calendar week, automatically by schedule (11 PM).
6. The backup software will store as many weeks of backup "sessions" as will fit on the connected drive. Another possibility is the declaration of a set number of sessions to retain.
7. The backup software will recognize which backup drive is connected and automatically use it for storing the backup sessions.
8. If the User forgets to change the backup drive, the backup software will continue to operate and store the backup sessions on the external drive until it becomes full.
9. The backup software will automatically manage the space on the external drives when the capacity is used up and delete the oldest backup sessions as needed to make room for new backup sessions.
10. The backup software will maintain a full catalog of the files backed up in each of the backup sessions in a database stored on the subject computer. The database will record which of the external backup drives contain each of the files in each of the backup sessions until the backup session is removed due to space needs.
11. The backup file catalog will have a search capability to allow locating any particular file(s) or folder(s) and displaying the available restore options by the modification date/time and identify which backup device(s) contain an available copy of the selected information for restoration.
12. The ability to fully restore the entire system to an empty hard disk, if needed.

What Acronis program is best suited to implement this type of backup plan for SOHO needs, if such software exists? In larger concerns, I have seen BrightStor ARCserve and Symantec BackupExec implemented to address most of the items in the above list, but each of these programs cost more than the computer being protected; however, it either of these will do the job, then so be it. Any information to help solve this need will be appreciated.

0 Users found this helpful

*****edited spelling errors****

Allan,

I think ABR11.5 Workstation might be better suited to what you want to do, but TIH 2013 can also be persuaded to do almost everything on your list. The one thing that neither product can do is to make an incremental to the 'wrong' disk for the following reason, they need to be able to 'see' the complete archive. If you were to make only full images then this would be possible so long as all the disks always shared the same drive letter.

A better way of doing this would be to make 4 tasks (one for each disk) and have each task run once a month. You would need to set the tasks up in their respective weeks the first time around or make them one day after another otherwise they will all run at once.

4. 2013 and ABR11.5 - tick

5. ditto - noting that ABR11.5 can offer more sophisticated imaging alogrithms such as GFS and tower of Hanoi.

6. You can set up task rules to accomplish this with both products.

7. See my opening comments.

8. ditto - full images this would work, incrementals no as the chain would be broken.

9.You set this up as part of the consolidation rules or with ABR11.5 this will happen automatically for some of the built in algorithms and you cna fine tune it with your own rules.

10. I'm not sure that either quite do what you want here, both can show you the images contained within an archive, with ABR11.5 there is also a catalogueing process, both products allow you to explore an image (or archive in ABR11.5 case) to the file level and both products are able to mount an archive as a virtual drive.

11. ABR11.5 will be the closest to this 'want' but I'm unsure that they will do this in the manner you would like.

12. They can both do this. If the drive image contains the system and partition and OS this is best done from the recovery CD , if they are just data disks or partitions these can be done from within Windows.

I suggest downloading the trial versions of 2013 and ABR11.5 Workstation and see if either of them suit you. You cannot install them together, only one can be installed at a time. ABR11.5 cannot read TIH 2013 images but 2013 can read ABR11.5 ones.

Colin,

WOW, what a rapid response and tremendously detailed information! Much more than other forums I have reviewed. I obviously have a lot of work to do to fully evaluate these two (very similar) products. I fully realize that I am looking for backup solutions here that are much more suited to a full server environment, but I have a lot of Clients that are small businesses and home-based businesses that really cannot afford the complexity and expense of a traditional Windows server system. I really think that if I can put this scenario together properly that there is a significant business opportunity for me in the north Texas area where I am based. Thanks so much for your wise and experienced information.

My User now wants to add another backup task that runs a full system backup to tape in addition to the normal backup to the external hard disk drive. Background: We had a motherboard failure on the original peer-to-peer server and had to re-task a recently retired Novell NetWare 6.5 server as the replacement Windows XP Professional peer-to-peer server. This is a HP Proliant server machine that works very well in the new role. It also has an internal DAT72 SCSI tape drive that is still in good working order. The backup software that comes with Windows XP Professional supports the tape drive correctly and will make a full backup of the system to the DAT72 tape, but each tape cartridge must be re-formatted manually in order to get the Windows Backup software to accept the tape (as best I can determine). The PROBLEM I now face is that Acronis ABR11.5 Workstation cannot seem to find the drive and does not show the menu item where the tape drive is supposed to appear as a backup destination when setting up the backup task that would add the tape backup functions. Do I need to install some additional driver(s) to get ABR11.5 Workstation to recognize and use the SCSI tape drive? Am I missing something, since I see that ABR11.5 Workstation supports tape drives as a backup destination? I await further wisdom for my situation.

Allan,

Caught me before going to bed :)

I believe ABR11.5 needs to have the Management Server installed and then add a Storage Node to that. I think Management Server requires a licence for ABR11.5 Advanced Workstation as a minimum. ***edit**** You will need the Advanced Workstation version - just checked the Acronis data sheets.

I don't have a tape drive so have never used this option. I suggest opening a thread in the ABR 11.5 forum asking this question.