Aller au contenu principal

Disk Cloning vs. Restore & Backup Disk Image vs. Back and restore partition

Thread needs solution

Normal
0

false
false
false

EN-US
X-NONE
X-NONE

MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

Normal
0

false
false
false

EN-US
X-NONE
X-NONE

MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

/* Style Definitions */
table.MsoNormalTable
{mso-style-name:"Table Normal";
mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0;
mso-tstyle-colband-size:0;
mso-style-noshow:yes;
mso-style-priority:99;
mso-style-parent:"";
mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt;
mso-para-margin:0in;
mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt;
mso-pagination:widow-orphan;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-family:"Times New Roman","serif";}

/* Style Definitions */
table.MsoNormalTable
{mso-style-name:"Table Normal";
mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0;
mso-tstyle-colband-size:0;
mso-style-noshow:yes;
mso-style-priority:99;
mso-style-parent:"";
mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt;
mso-para-margin:0in;
mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt;
mso-pagination:widow-orphan;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-family:"Times New Roman","serif";}

Disk Cloning vs. Restore & Backup Disk Image vs. Back and restore partition

Hi All and especially GroverH,

First of all thanks to everyone and especially GroverH for sharing vast expertise knowledge.

I am visiting forums and using Acronis after a gap of year or little more and have been reading each forum post from last several years.

Before I raise my queries / doubts I would like to detail  how I used Acronis in past and why:

1. Cloning was the function I used most –

Reason: Fastest and simplest way to create a bootable exact copy of my internal laptop hard disk to external USB hard disk with all data backup automatically done.

Advantage: No brainer, least amount of time taken, data backup created whenever I did clone for creating a clone

2. Infact I never even created or have used rescue CD or it seems now called  rescue media etc

My doubts / queries now

I have seen after reading Acronis KB website and so so many forum posts for several hours is that its asked to place new (to be used as target) hard drive inside laptop and take internal original hard disk (source) outside. Further create first disk image and then restore it rather than cloning.   I understand that cloning has some risks. I never experienced in past but I am no expert and not a professional so rely on the fact that many people have faced it and so I better avoid using cloning. However my pain points are:

1.       Why Acronis gives cloning feature if it can risk source (which vitiates purpose of backup?)?

2.       Using the long process (to my understanding its very long when compared with clone) of first creating full image backup and then restoring from image (or at least testing simulating that backup image is bootable) weekly is a painful process in terms of two steps and time consumption vis a vis clone. I have seen posts on forum wherein people are reporting huge time in creating backups. Any ideas here?

3.       What if I want to only make periodic data backup (as against OS backup) using Acronis TI full data backup vis a vis clone? Is a clone not recommended even for data backup when I don’t want target drive to be bootable?

4.       Can I use restore partition only method to selectively back up and if needed restore C (os partition) only. Likewise only D (data partition)?

5.       How has been the experience of pluspack for restoring image to different laptop? Is it worth it or does it create many issues?

Appreciate kind guidance and view points / opinions.

Thanks for your tim

0 Users found this helpful

First, I would suggest that you edit your prior posting and delete all the non-readable coding.

To answer your question from my viewpoint--

1. All vendors has this risk factor. You cannot predict what will happen when the user wrongly clones the new drive overtop the old drive; or when the power goes out; or attempting to clone on a battery; or a hardware malfunction. When none of these go wrong, a clone can be successful--if the correct procedures used.

2. As for time consumption, yes cloning is somewhat faster. The cloning is copying the disk contents from one disk to another disk. Restoring a backup is copying the disk contents into a file and then mostly the same amount of time added to restore the file. The USB3 type drives and computers have improved the speeds a great deal.

3. Whether cloning or restoring, either is a matter of user choice. Some users have better success using one method over the other but it is user preference. Your best chances of having a successful clone (bootable or data only) is when the clone is done from the TI bootable media CD or flash drive. Not having Windows involved reduces the risks of program interference. I do not speak for Acronis but their recommendation is and has been for quite some time to use the TI bootable media when cloning or restsoring a system partition. Cloning is only at disk level. Cloning produces two (mostly) identical disks. If you want less than a disk copied or cloned, this can only be done by means of a backup and restore.

4. Your best backup is a full and complete backup of the entire disk to include all partitions. SEE NOTE. Once you have that complete backup, it can be used to restore single or multiple partitions only within a multi-partition disk. When restoring C only and if C is not the active partition, you may also have to restore the active partition along with the drive C (Win7 & 8). Note: single partitons backups can also work but be sure and include the boot/active partition with the backup Drive C in Vista or Win7/8. If the disk has multiple partitions, restoring a full backup (as compared to single partition backups)is usually more successful when a replacement disk. Different users have different preferences and different skill levels so no "one size fits all" is applicable.

5. No comments to offer regarding the plus pack. It's intention is to offer a WINPE recovery disk capabilitiy; and to offer a means of recoving a backup to the same computer which may have a new MB,etc. It is not really intended to moving from one computer to another with the same backup file. Do more research on this forum if interested in the plus pack. Link to Grovers Guides:
http://forum.acronis.com/forum/3426

-------------------------------------------------------------
You will find guides to creating new replacment disks via both the cloning method as well as the backup/restore method. It's your choice bu mine choice is the backup and restore method.

Link to Grovers Guides:
http://forum.acronis.com/forum/3426
Extract below:

3. Grover's Guides & Miscellaneous Information
New       AA. TIH2012 Restore to larger or smaller disk - pdf download
New       BB. TIH2012 Disk option restore - pdf download
New       CC. TIH2012 Restore Drive C only - pdf download
New       DD. 28705: Grover's How to Backup 2012 from within Windows. Pictures or Screen show
New       EE. Grover's How to Backup 2010 or 2009
New       FF. Grover's V11-8101 How to Backup & Restore Screen show  Download/Unzip/Run
New       GG. Grover's How to prevent Win7 computers from going to sleep during backups - Pdf download
New       HH. Grover's How to copy single files from Backup file or mounted backup - Pdf download
New       PP. MVP Scott's Guide to Restoring Sony S-Series SVS15113FXS with ati2012 build 7133 BootCd
    QQ. Add Disk Option:Disk prep before cloning or recovering new disk.
    RR. KB2931: Cloning Laptop Hard Disk
    SS. KB2770: Acronis True Image: Resizing Partitions during Restore to Larger/Smaller Hard Drive
    TT. New disk needed: Clone or Restore a Backup Commentary?
    UU. PDF Guide: Upgrading to larger disk via 2009-2010-2011 using Partition Restore with Resize                         Win-7 Compaq Laptop  or  Win-7 Gateway laptop
    VV. PDF Guide: Upgrading to larger disk via 2009-2010-2011 using Manual Cloning                        Win-7 Compaq Laptop
    XX. PDF Guide: Upgrading to smaller disk via 2009-2010-2011 using Manual Cloning                        Win-7 Gateway Laptop

    YY. Older versions: Two Beginner "How to" Guides for Vers 9-10-11: Backup Guide PDF Here  and  Restore Guide PDF Here or   a zip file here
    ZZ. Older versions:PDF Guide: Upgrading to larger harddrive V9-10-11     or    A zip file here

New      H. How to use Win7 scheduler to run TIH backup tasks
    I. How to use Windows XP Task Schedule Every 3 days and  Schedule Every 2 weeks
    J. How a disk restore results varies by version.
    K. Guide: Cloning using V9-10-11

    L. TrueImageHome "Partition or Disk to Restore" Screen--Alternate View
    M. How to use Windows Task Schedule Every 3 days and  Schedule Every 2 weeks
    N. Considering an external drive, then consider a dual purpose combination
        and with additional comments by contributor Fungus.

    P. TrueImage Home Install paths.
    Q. 9401: Create Backup Desktop Shortcuts plus added comments from post 8500
    R. 6013: Use TrueImage Home to Shutdown computer after backup completion.
    S. 7400: One-Click Backup - Understand its limitations & what is actually included.
    T. Successful recovery to larger disk using Thinkpad X61     Added-1     Added-2     Added-3